Musings of a Designer on Jewelry, Crochet, Crochet Patterns, Knitting, Running a Crafty Business, Movie Costumes, Books, Art, Design, Steampunk & the Geek Girl Life

Monday, December 01, 2008

Marie Antoinette Barbie vs. Queen Elizabeth Barbie

It's time for some eye candy! Barbie dolls sure have come a long way since I was a kid. LOVE these decked out limited edition collector's Barbies!Marie Antoinette Barbie DollMarie Antoinette is looking lovely wearing an awesome pale blue dress and her jewels. I definitely think this is the prettier of the dolls. When you think about Marie Antoinette, it's all about the fashion, the style, the luxe. Not much of a ruler though. We all know how her story ended. Recently, she has been presented in a more favorable light. But icon of style that she was, historically she was a weak and ineffectual queen.
Queen Elizabeth I Barbie Doll
Let's contrast Marie with Elizabeth I! Elizabeth is looking regal in her Tudor finery. Her court clothes visually communicated power and wealth in a very different way than Marie Antoinette. Marie definitely had the more feminine outfits, but for all-around monarch it's hard to beat Elizabeth I. When she ascended the throne in 1558, England was an impoverished country torn apart by religious squabbles. When she died at Richmond Palace on the 24th March 1603, England was one of the most powerful and prosperous countries in the world. A successful and popular queen.

So .... I like them both! Marie Antoinette for the pretty (Cinderella would be jealous) and Elizabeth for representing what that monarch accomplished.

Which one do you like better??
Other posts you might enjoy:
Marie Antoinette: Pretty, Pretty Shoes
Heat Wave


Gracie said...

I think I definitely think the Marie Antoinette doll is prettier. Her dress is amazing!!
But the Elizabeth I is also good and yes her being a great Queen also makes the doll more attractive.
If I was going to ever buy one though it would be Marie Antoinette. I just adore that dress =)

Lori said...

well aren't they fantastical? my barbies never looked that good!!!

Leigh Ann said...

I don't know that I've ever commented on your blog before, although I read it regularly (I got here a long time ago from your etsy shop), but incidentally, I am actually looking to sell my Queen Elizabeth, still in the box and everything. I was going to put it on ebay or something, but I hadn't gotten around to it, what with basically hating ebay these days. So, if you're actually looking for one, I'm SleepySlug on Etsy, and the same with a - between the words on Ebay.

Scrappy Jessi said...

hey sweets,
i love that Barbie!!!
Hope yo are having a happy holiday season.

Heather said...

I'm quite into Elizabeth at the moment so I'll vote for her!

nuvonova said...

Wow! I've never seen these before. definitely prefer Queen Elizabeth!

Anonymous said...

I like Liz doll because of the attention to detail in the high lace collar, the hairstyle, and the ornaments. And I like the style of dress better.

Sandy Michelle said...

Awwww. thanks so much for the congrats!!!! I love those Marie barbies! The first one really looks like Marie but I love the hair on the second one:)

Sandy xox

Anonymous said...

Marie Barbie wow! I have to go talk to Santa!

kari and kijsa said...

Stunning! Hard to choose, but we might take the fanciful Marie as our favorite!
Happy Saturday!
kari & kijsa

NeereAnDear said...

STUNNING!!!! I absolutely love them both!! The details... the dresses... they are both regal in their own way... simply beautiful!!

You are so right in saying Barbie has come a long way... I cant imagine the cost of these beauties...

Wanted to stop by and wish you the Merriest of Christmases and even Happier New Year!!



Esther said...

they are both great. never knew they did Barbies like that!

the wreath witch said...

although Marie is beautiful and so is her gown .
Elizabeth is regal... I like her best here.

Anonymous said...

Okay I get that making dolls of important female figures is a good thing, i think. But Marie? is her head detachable? She was both the victim and perpetrator of bad things that lead to the revolution. Lets take a minute before we romanticize certain figures please.

Bejeweled said...

Hi there Anonymous! I'm no fan of Marie, as you might be able to tell from my post, but she is very popular now in pop culture for reasons that have nothing to do with history or historical accuracy. I'm sure the Barbie version is merely capitalizing on that fad.

Thanks for your comment .. it's always good to express one's thoughts and to have a healthy debate!

ainsley said...

There booth so pretty!!

Andy said...

I think weighing up Marie Antoinette as a queen against Elizabeth I is a bit unfair. Elizabeth was the sole monarch of her country, and was in full control of her kingdom. Marie Antoinette was simply Queen Consort of France, a role which really offered her no power whatsoever. Not only this but her husband had been brought up from an early age not to trust his future wife's influence with politics or interference in royal business. She was merely keeping her head down and indulging in the pleasures of Versailles that she was expected to as Queen. All in all Marie Antoinette is a victim of propaganda and circumstance.

Tatieva artiste said...

Wouah, elle est absolument divine, cette Marie-Antoinette ! Je l'adore ! Je collectionne aussi les Barbie de collection, celle-ci, je ne l'ai pas ! Merveilleuse, romantique, amazing !
Love, love, love !
J'ai imaginé une peinture de Marie-Antoinette avec des macarons... ;-)))

Daryl Q. said...

Doll wise I love the Marie Antoinette is beautiful. But, I would buy the Elizabeth I doll. She was such an extraordinary historical figure!

Breanna said...

Amazing! Your doll is Gorgeous! So pretty! I wish that was my doll! Where did you get her? The dress is beautiful! I wish i could where it.